Dynasty Buy High Sell High: 4 Stars to Target and 4 to Dump

Keon Coleman

Dynasty Football Buy High Sell High

Two weeks into the NFL season, dynasty managers are panicking like their first-round QB just fumbled the opening drive. Some are overreacting, some are chasing hype, and some are convinced their waiver-wire grab is the next Patrick Mahomes. That’s the beauty of dynasty: if you can keep your cool while everyone else is hitting the panic button, you can turn chaos into profit.

Here’s the plan: I’ll break down four players you should be buying now before the price skyrockets and four players to sell before their value craters. Consider it your dynasty market cheat sheet — less Wall Street, more end zone, with just enough chaos to make it fun.

[the_ad id=”105842″]

 

Four Players to Buy [mks_icon icon=”fa-line-chart” color=”#333″ type=”fa”]

Rashee Rice

WR, Kansas City Chiefs

Rice’s six-game suspension tanked his short-term value, but the dynasty window is wide open. As a rookie in 2023, he ranked No. 9 among WRs in Yards After Catch per Reception (6.6) and posted a 26% Targets Per Route Run (TPRR), per PlayerProfiler — elite alpha-level metrics. He already earned Patrick Mahomes’ trust, and once he returns, Rice has a clear path to reclaiming the WR1 role in Kansas City.

Dynasty Outlook: WR2 floor, WR1 ceiling tied to Mahomes.

Trey Benson

RB, Arizona Cardinals

The second-year player is already flashing big-play ability. Through two games, Benson has 11 carries for 83 rushing yards (7.5 YPC), per ESPN logs. For context, starter James Conner has 26 carries for 84 yards (3.2 YPC). Benson doesn’t need huge volume to produce — his college profile featured a 95th-percentile Speed Score (110.8) on PlayerProfiler. With Kyler Murray healthy, this offense looks functional, and Benson is positioned to take over the backfield sooner rather than later.

Dynasty Outlook: Explosive RB2 with realistic RB1 upside in 2025.

[the_ad id=”104525″]

Keon Coleman

WR, Buffalo Bills

The raw counting stats don’t pop yet, but his role and efficiency are highly encouraging. At Florida State, Coleman boasted a 19.3% College Target Share and averaged 19.2 yards per catch (No. 4) among NFL WRs in 2024, per PlayerProfiler. He also ranked No. 5 in Average Depth of Target (15.5 yards) and top-5 in Yards After Catch per Reception (7.7). Translation: he’s both a vertical and post-catch weapon. With Josh Allen looking for a true WR1, Coleman’s ceiling is massive.

Dynasty Outlook: Buy now before the breakout; potential WR1 tethered to Josh Allen.

Dalton Kincaid

TE, Buffalo Bills

Sophomore tight ends rarely offer elite usage, but Kincaid is already an exception. In 2024, he ran a route on 77% of Josh Allen’s dropbacks (PlayerProfiler) and earned a 17% Target Share, both top-12 among TEs. He also logged 1.73 Yards per Route Run, a strong efficiency marker at the position. Kincaid is already in that “next elite” tier — but his dynasty value hasn’t caught up yet.

Dynasty Outlook: A future top-5 TE, potentially as soon as 2025.

 

Four Players to Sell [mks_icon icon=”fa-shopping-basket” color=”#333″ type=”fa”]

 

C.J. Stroud

QB, Houston Texans

Stroud is incredible, but his dynasty valuation is sky-high — currently QB2/QB3 in many ranks. Through two weeks of 2025, he’s averaging 7.0 Yards per Attempt on 27 pass attempts, per PlayerProfiler/ESPN. That’s strong, but his 2024 spike year featured a +29.5 Production Premium (No. 2 among QBs) — a metric that typically regresses. You’re not selling Stroud because he’s bad; you’re selling because his value is at its absolute peak.

Dynasty Outlook: Sell high for a king’s ransom.

Tyrone Tracy

RB, New York Giants

Tracy enters his second NFL season with high expectations, but his dynasty stock may be overheated. Through two weeks, he’s averaging just 2.9 yards per carry with a 37% snap share, per PlayerProfiler, while fellow rookie Cam Skattebo has impressed with explosive runs and efficient touches. The Giants’ backfield is crowded, and Tracy’s touches have been inconsistent, making it clear that the team is still figuring out the pecking order.

Dynasty Outlook: Talented second-year back, but Skattebo’s strong early-season performance and shared workload make Tracy a sell-high candidate before his role stabilizes.

Terry McLaurin

WR, Washington Commanders

McLaurin is still steady, but his role is shrinking. His Average Depth of Target (8.2 yards) through two weeks is the lowest of his career, per PlayerProfiler. The addition of Deebo Samuel has also cut into his opportunities — Samuel has siphoned off manufactured touches and short-area volume, leaving McLaurin more dependent on low-leverage looks. With rookie Luke McCaffrey emerging as a vertical option, McLaurin is caught in the middle, trending toward a floor WR2 rather than a ceiling play. At 29, this is the last window to move him for meaningful value.

Dynasty Outlook: Still productive, but Deebo’s presence accelerates the decline — sell one year early rather than one too late.

Chase Brown

RB, Cincinnati Bengals

Chase Brown’s 2025 season has been underwhelming. Through the first two games, he has accumulated just 90 rushing yards on 37 carries, averaging a mere 2.4 yards per carry. This performance places him among the least efficient running backs in the league.

The Bengals’ offense faces additional challenges with quarterback Joe Burrow sidelined for at least three months due to a severe turf toe injury. Without Burrow’s presence, defenses are likely to focus more on stopping the run, potentially stacking the box and further limiting Brown’s opportunities.

Dynasty Outlook: Given his current inefficiency and the team’s offensive adjustments, now is the time to sell Brown before his value diminishes further.

Dynasty football isn’t about chasing last week’s glory — it’s about seeing the market before everyone else does. Buy the players who others are sleeping on, sell the ones whose hype has peaked, and remember: patience is your secret weapon (right after spreadsheets and a little bit of gut instinct). Make your moves now, and next time your league mate panics over a rookie fumble, you’ll be the one laughing all the way to the championship.

 

Share This Article

This Article Written By