Cam Skattebo Fantasy Impact 2025

Cam Skattebo Fantasy Impact 2025

The New York Giants, coming off the horror film of their 3 -14 season, are poised to screen the sequel in 2025. Facing one of the most grueling schedules in recent memory, the once mighty Giants are feared by no man. Whilst yes, they have some intriguing pieces heading into the year, their team is one giant question mark after another.

There are some bright spots on the roster, and Jackson Dart’s preseason performance might provide a glimmer of hope. But one can’t help but worry about what’s in store for the next six months (or four and a half months, if you’re being honest with yourselves, Giants fans).

Despite all of the above, Cam Skattebo is one rookie that has the football cognoscenti flush in the face, a hopeless crush on the 4th round pick who has practically been hailed as the usurper of the RB1 position. Well, if you feel this way, or if you drafted Cam Skattebo, look away now because this one might get ugly.

Offensive Playcalling

In 2024, Head Coach Brian Daboll took the play-calling duties from Mike Kafka’s grasp, hoping to revive the offense. Safe to say he didn’t do that. So up until pre-season, we didn’t know if he would continue to call plays or hand back the headset. Turns out it’s the latter, and even I can accept the Giants have looked better in pre-season. But it is pre-season. So miss me with the hot takes about Kafka being the solution, when his team are playing a bunch of third-stringers, whom, respectfully, might be your next insurance sales rep. Not to mention, when he was last calling plays he publicly talked about his focus on building an explosive pass attack. That was with Tommy Cutlets and Drew Lock slinging it. You have to think that with Russel Wilson at the helm, who still undoubtedly throws a lovely moon ball, that will be his focus again.

Offensive Line

The biggest (and only) upgrade here is LT Andrew Thomas returning. Let’s not assume he is healthy and in form, given his injury limited him to 6 games last season. But if he is, he was performing as a top 5 tackle in 2022; if he can continue to do so, that will help. However, outside of that, the line is dismal, and I’d suspect they will be in the bottom 5 this season as well.

Fantasy Impact

So, all of this leads me to Mr. Cameron Skattebo. A 4th round selection who enters a running back room currently led by Tyrone Tracy Jr. Now, I’m sure you can work out by now that this is not going to be a pro-Skattebo article. Ironically, you could point to Tracy as your evidence for why Skattebo could work. Tracy, a 5th rounder, was drafted by the Giants last year and took the lead role from Devin Singletary, who had previous year stats scarily similar to 2024 Tyrone Tracy:

  • Devin Singletary, 2023, 898 yards, 4.2 YPC, 4 TD, 30 Receptions
  • Tyrone Tracy, 2024, 839 yards, 4.4 YPC, 5 TD, 38 Receptions

So you could argue that Tracy got the lead role, which means Skattebo, entering the same offense and coaching room could do the same. But Cam Skattebo is not Tyrone Tracy Jr.

He was used as a receiver in college a lot, but Tracy is still the better receiver here. As a power back he is going to get some goal-line work, that’s undeniable. But his lack of pass-blocking skills and Tracy’s superior receiving skills are going to limit Skattebo’s use.

Even if you used Tracy as your test case here, he wasn’t given a proper shot until Singletary was injured. So Skattebo getting a real run would hinge on Tracy being injured. In fact, to further exaggerate Tyrone Tracy’s numbers, they are actually skewed negatively. If you exclude his time out of the lead chair, he averaged 13.1 FPPG.

Add to that, Skattebo has already had injury issues that delayed his preseason debut to the final game, where he got 3 totes for 12 yards (4 YPC) – nothing to be excited about. I’ll acknowledge he ran some passing routes, and they looked ok but I’ll also acknowledge he didn’t see a target.

To lay off the Haterade for a quick second, there is a path to relevance for Cam in 2+ years. But you are much better off buying low at the end of the season if he shows flashes.

The thing here is, sometimes the fantasy world takes a college darling under its wing and spends the entire offseason pumping them up. If I read about how he “runs angry” again, I’m going to pull my hair out. Plenty of elite backs “run angry”. Derrick Henry most famously, but that isn’t his superpower. It’s the vision and patience – running angry can break tackles in the open field but it can’t get you into open field.

I’ll summarize with a take that is going to age like Tom Brady or Ben Roethlisberger – Skattebo’s situation, competition, and skill deficiencies project for a lackluster rookie year. DO NOT draft him at his current ADP. Watch for flashes this year, and watch Jaxson Dart. If he has the makings of a breakout candidate, and the Giants address their line in free agency. If all that happens and Skattebo has shown sparks, then use a later pick to try acquire him in early April next year.

 

Share This Article

This Article Written By